← Terug naar overzicht Taal: NL EN

Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding.

Albert Einstein

Message to the *New York Times*, 1930 (advocating for a world government) · Gecheckt op 27 februari 2026
Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding.

Analyse

Einstein’s 1930 *New York Times* piece (titled *'To the Heroes of the War Resisters'*) emphasized moral resistance over militarism and supported a supranational authority to prevent war, aligning with the *sentiment* of the quoted statement. However, the specific phrasing—'**Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding**'—does not appear verbatim in that article or his known 1930 writings. The line closely resembles later paraphrases of his views (e.g., in 1950s anti-nuclear advocacy) and may be a condensed distillation of his philosophy. Without a direct citation from the *Times* in 1930, the attribution is *partially accurate* but lacks precise sourcing.

Achtergrond

Einstein was a vocal pacifist in the 1920–30s, though his stance evolved post-WWII to support *limited* military action against fascism. His 1930 *New York Times* contribution argued that war resistance required systemic change, not violence, and he later expanded these ideas in essays like *'Why War?'* (1932, with Freud). The quoted phrase circulates widely online but is often misattributed to specific texts without primary-source verification.

Samenvatting verdict

While Einstein *did* advocate for a world government in 1930 and frequently spoke on peace, this exact phrasing appears to be a paraphrase of his broader ideas rather than a direct, verified quote from the *New York Times* that year.

Geraadpleegde bronnen

— Einstein, A. (1930, December 14). *To the Heroes of the War Resisters*. The New York Times (Archive: ProQuest Historical Newspapers)
— Einstein, A. & Freud, S. (1932). *Why War?* International Institute of Intellectual Co-operation, League of Nations (reprinted in *Einstein on Peace*, 1960)
— Calaprice, A. (2010). *The Ultimate Quotable Einstein*. Princeton University Press (pp. 384–385, noting no exact match for the quote in Einstein’s 1930 writings)
— The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein, Vol. 10 (1997). Princeton University Press (no matching phrase in 1930 correspondence)