Analyse
The statement was made during an **impromptu press conference** aboard the papal plane on **July 28, 2013**, while returning from World Youth Day in Rio de Janeiro. When asked about reports of a 'gay lobby' in the Vatican and the status of gay priests, Francis responded with the now-famous phrase, emphasizing **mercy over judgment** for those seeking God with goodwill. The remark was **officially transcribed** by the Vatican and reported by major outlets like *The New York Times*, *Reuters*, and *Catholic News Service*. His words marked a **shift in tone** (though not doctrine) on LGBTQ+ issues compared to previous papal rhetoric.
Achtergrond
The comment came amid broader discussions about reform in the Catholic Church, particularly regarding its approach to LGBTQ+ individuals. While Francis did not alter Church teaching on homosexuality (which still considers same-sex acts 'intrinsically disordered'), his **pastoral emphasis on inclusion** contrasted with prior public statements by Vatican officials. The remark was later cited in debates about the Church’s stance on LGBTQ+ rights, clergy, and the 2023 *Fiducia Supplicans* declaration allowing blessings for same-sex couples in certain contexts.
Samenvatting verdict
Pope Francis did make the 'Who am I to judge?' remark about gay individuals in 2013, as widely reported and confirmed by the Vatican.